Poker-Star Phil Ivey Forced to Repay $10.1m in Edge Sorting Case

January 9th, 2017

SHARE

Poker-Star Phil Ivey Forced to Repay $10.1m in Edge Sorting Case

Professional poker player Phil Ivey has been ordered to repay more than $10 million in winnings after a judge ruled that he and his partner breached the rules of baccarat at the Borgata Casino in Atlantic City in 2012.

Ivey and fellow player Cheng Yin Sun acquired $9.6 million during four separate sessions of mini-baccarat over the year, using a method called edge sorting, which the casino claimed violates state casino gambling regulations.

Explaining Edge Sorting

Edge sorting is a technique whereby players identify tiny differences in the symmetry on the back of cards in order to determine whether a face-down card is likely to be low or high. It requires the collaboration of the croupier who sorts and arranges the good cards so that the players involved can identify them.

Since many packs of cards are asymmetric, this technique can be exploited to gain advantage in casino table games. There is some debate as to whether edge sorting is actually cheating or not. Ivey did not deny that he was guilty of edge sorting but he believes he was simply using good skill and observation as any player should.

In any case, the practice is considered as cheating by most casinos in most countries. After a long legal case, it was ruled that Ivey and Sun must return the money they won plus interest, alongside money Ivey won playing craps with his winnings, to the Borgata Casino.

What Did Phil Ivey Do and Why are They Punishing Him?

The judge in the case noted that Ivey and his companion had instructed the dealers in their four games to arrange the cards in a certain way – which is actually permitted under the rules of baccarat – after Sun had noticed tiny differences in the cards. In October the judge ruled that Ivey and Sun’s actions violated the state Casino Control Act, which they were obliged to abide by in gambling at the casino:

"By using cards they caused to be maneuvered in order to identify their value only to them, Ivey and Sun adjusted the odds of baccarat in their favour. This is in complete contravention of the fundamental purpose of legalised gambling."

The Borgata Casino also made a claim for so-called “expectation damages” of $5.4 million, which is the amount they believe the pair would have lost had they not used edge sorting, but this was rejected by the judge as it was deemed too hypothetical. Phil Ivey has vowed to appeal the decision, with Ed Jacobs, his attorney, stating:

"What this ruling says is a player is prohibited from combining his skill and intellect and visual acuity to beat the casino at its own game… The casino agreed to every single accommodation requested by Phil Ivey in his four visits because they were eager to try to win his money."

Déjà Vu for Ivey

Phil Ivey is one of real life and online poker’s biggest stars, winning ten World Series of Poker bracelets and a World Poker Tour title. Though he does not seem to have much luck when it comes to legal cases; the American was on another occasion involved in an almost identical case, which also related to an incident from 2012.

This time, it was Ivey who was pressing the claim after Genting Casinos UK refused to transfer the money he won while playing a version of baccarat called Punto Banco at the Crockfords Club in Mayfair, London. Again, Ivey used the method of edge sorting to help him acquire his winnings, but instead of wiring the funds to him, the casino simply refunded his £1 million stake.

Ivey challenged Genting, which owns the club, at the High Court in 2014 and again at the Court of Appeal in 2016, but lost on both occasions. The judges ruled that he, and his accomplice Cheng Yin Sun, had cheated. It was not a great 2016 for Ivey, who was largely absent on the Poker Tour circuit due to his legal battles. It appears that, for now at least, the law is on the side of the casinos when it comes to edge sorting.

Poker News Articles


New Action Squad Tournament at 888poker Offers $100k Daily
New Action Squad Tournament at 888poker Offers $100k Daily

888poker’s recent trend of tailoring more tournaments and promotions took another step forward recently with the launch of the Action Squad. Designed to incorporate the best of the operator’s quirky M ... Read More

First Round of Major Improvements Launched at PartyPoker
First Round of Major Improvements Launched at PartyPoker

PartyPoker has come a long way from its roots as a network of sites under the iGlobalMedia group in 1997. However, never one to keep a low profile or rest on its laurels, this icon of the online poker ... Read More

888poker Releases Flopomania and Push or Fold Flopomania
888poker Releases Flopomania and Push or Fold Flopomania

888poker has finally released the much anticipated Flopomania AND Push or Fold Flopomania. The games are designed to increase speed of play and have a broader appeal as well as go hand-in-hand with 88 ... Read More

First-Time WSOP Rookie Wins Third Largest Main Event Ever
First-Time WSOP Rookie Wins Third Largest Main Event Ever

The 2017 World Series of Poker (WSOP) was yet another example of how the game can change a player's life in just a few days. As has happened multiple times over the past few years, the latest $10,000 ... Read More

PartyPoker Live Promises $35m in Guarantees Next Powerfest
PartyPoker Live Promises $35m in Guarantees Next Powerfest

PartyPoker is adding some more zing to its latest POWERFEST with an extra $15 million in guaranteed prize money. Following on from a successful outing in March where $20 million was on the table, Part ... Read More

WSOP Europe Bumps Main Event Prize from €4m to €5m for 2017
WSOP Europe Bumps Main Event Prize from €4m to €5m for 2017

Following another record-breaking event in Las Vegas over the summer, the World Series of Poker (WSOP) has decided to offer up more money in Europe this October. With news that the World Series of Pok ... Read More

Poker Navigation

Newsletter

Sign up for the free Gambling.com Newsletter to stay on top of all the best bonuses!
We will never share or misuse your personal information. Privacy Policy

Latest Poker News

PokerGuides

Country Guide