Five of the Biggest Betting Upsets in FA Cup History

Five of the Biggest Betting Upsets in FA Cup History

From Bradford beating Jose Mourinho's Chelsea to Colchester beating Don Revie's Leeds, Gambling.com picks out our favourite ever FA Cup Betting upsets.


Colchester United 3-2 Leeds United, Fifth Round (1971)

Leeds were victims of one of the biggest FA Cup Final shocks in history when they were beaten 1-0 by Second Division Sunderland in 1973. Yet their defeat by Colchester two years earlier was even more eyebrow-raising, as Don Revie’s formidable side fell to a 3-2 loss at Layer Road.

Leeds arrived in Essex as favourites to win both the FA Cup and the First Division but departed with their tails firmly between their legs. Johnny Giles, Jack Charlton, Norman Hunter and Peter Lorimer were all part of a star-studded visiting side, although captain Billy Bremner was unavailable for selection for this fifth-round clash.

A quick-fire double from Ray Crawford put Colchester in dreamland after 25 minutes, before Dave Simmons further extended their advantage early in the second half. Goals from Hunter and Giles made for a nervy finish, but Colchester held on to send Revie’s mighty Leeds crashing out.


Wrexham 2-1 Arsenal, Third Round (1992)

George Graham described this defeat as his “lowest moment in football”, which goes some way to explaining how much of a shock Wrexham’s victory was.

The Fourth Division side were expected to be soundly beaten by a team containing Tony Adams, Paul Merson, Lee Dixon, David O’Leary, Alan Smith, David Seaman and David Rocastle, and their chances of clinging on for a replay were damaged when Smith gave the Gunners the lead in the 43rd minute.

Yet Arsenal were unable to find a second goal to put the game to bed, a failure for which they were made to pay late on. First, captain Mickey Thomas smashed a free-kick past Seaman to restore parity in the 82nd minute, before Steve Watkin punished a Nigel Winterburn mistake to take the roof off the Racecourse Ground.


Chelsea 2-4 Bradford City, Fourth Round (2015)

Perhaps the biggest shock of the modern era came at Stamford Bridge in 2015, although there was little sign of the script being ripped up after 38 minutes: Jose Mourinho’s side, who would go on to win the Premier League title a few months later, were 2-0 up at that stage of the match thanks to goals from Gary Cahill and Ramires.

With Didier Drogba, Petr Cech, Cesar Azpilicueta, Oscar and Mohamed Salah (whatever happened to him?) also on the pitch, the Blues seemingly had one foot in the fifth round before the interval.

Jon Stead halved the deficit for the League One side in the 41st minute, before a late flurry of goals turned the tie on its head. Cesc Fabregas and Willian had been introduced by the time Filipe Morais equalised with a quarter of an hour left to play, and Eden Hazard was thrown on immediately after that concession.

Not that it helped: goals from Andy Halliday and Mark Yeates completed an astonishing comeback for the Bantams, leading Mourinho to brandish his side’s exit a “disgrace”.


Sutton United 2-1 Coventry City, Third Round (1989)

In 2016/17 Sutton became only the ninth non-league team to reach the fifth round of the FA Cup since 1945. Their 1-0 defeat of Championship side Leeds United in the fourth round will live long in the memories of all those who witnessed it, but you have to go back to 1989 to find the greatest upset in the club’s history.

When Sutton, then in the Conference, were drawn against Coventry in the third round, the London outfit were determined to enjoy their big day out. And they certainly did that, as goals from captain Tony Rains and Matthew Hanlan either side of half-time gave United their most triumph of all time.

Coventry were a top-tier team who had won the competition two years earlier and whose starting XI featured several international players, but they came unstuck in front of 8000 fans at Gander Green Lane.


Hereford 2-1 Newcastle United, Third Round Replay (1972)

John Motson was just 26 years old when he was handed the microphone for Hereford’s third round replay against Newcastle in 1972. This was the first time many had heard the BBC commentator describe a game, and the stunning nature of the result did his career no harm whatsoever.

Fifth-tier Hereford had held top-flight Newcastle to a 2-2 draw in the original game, but the Magpies’ superior quality was expected to tell at Edgar Street. Malcolm Macdonald finally put the visitors in front with a header in the 82nd minute, but Ronnie Radford struck back with a superb 30-yard goal to level the scores and force extra time.

That equaliser seem to knock the stuffing out of Newcastle, and things got even worse when Ricky George gave Hereford an improbable lead in the 103rd minute. That strike prompted a pitch invasion from delirious Bulls fans, as the non-league side held on for a famous triumph which remains one of the most surprising in FA Cup history.

Recommended Betting Sites

shield of trust Secure trusted partners Trusted star verified Verified
Affiliate Disclosure: At Gambling.com, we want to ensure that players are matched with the right casino and sportsbook offers for them. For this reason, some of the recommended site links are affiliate links. This means that if you visit a website through our link and make a deposit, Gambling.com will receive a commission payment at no extra cost to you. At Gambling.com, we want to ensure that players are matched with the right casino and sportsbook offers for them. For this reason, some of the recommended site links are affiliate links. More
  1. Place £10, Get £40 in Free Bets + £10 on Casino
    Promo Code: 10FREE

  2. Bet £10 Get £30 in Free Bets

  3. Get up to £100 in Bet Credits!

  4. Bet £10 and Get £20 Welcome Offer

  5. Welcome Bonus Bet £10 Get £20

  6. Deposit £10 Get £10 Free Bet

    18+ New Players only. For free bet wagering requirements and minimum odds read T&C’s. www.begambleaware.org Terms Apply New players only. Free Bet is a one-time stake of £10, minimum odds of 1.5, stake is not returned. 10X wagering the winnings. Wagering occurs from real balance first. Wagering requirement is calculated on bonus bets only, wagering starts from real funds. Max conversion: £20. Valid for 7 days from issue. Excluded Skrill deposits. 18+. Play Responsibly www.begambleaware.org. Visit Site
  7. EXCLUSIVE: Bet £15, Get £10

  8. Bet £10 Get £20

    18+ New Players only. For free bet wagering requirements and minimum odds read T&C’s. www.begambleaware.org Terms Apply The Promotion operates as a £/€20 Surprise Bet when you place a bet of at least £/€10 on any market with odds greater than or equal to 1.50 as your first bet. The Promotion runs from 09/08/2021 / 12:00 (BST) until 31/12/2021 / 12:00 (BST) (the “Promotional Period”). The Promotion is only valid to: (a) new customers; (b) customers aged 18 years or over. To qualify for the Promotion, participant must deposit and place a £/€10 bet as their first bet on any market (excluding each way) in the sportsbook with odds greater than or equal to 1.50. Only original odds count toward the promotion. Supercharged odds do not count towards the promotion. An accumulation of smaller stakes will not count. Cashed out bets do not count towards this promotion. Only available once per customer. Rewards will be credited to qualifying participants within 48 hours after placing the qualifying bet. Potential winnings from the Surprise Bet are paid in withdrawable cash, excluding the stake. This offer cannot be used in conjunction with any other offer. Visit Site
  9. Bet £10, Get £10 Free Bet

    18+ New Players only. For free bet wagering requirements and minimum odds read T&C’s. www.begambleaware.org Terms Apply New players only. The qualifying bets to claim the Free Bet must have minimum odds of 3/1 (4.00) or higher and must be settled before triggering free bet. 18+. begambleaware.org - Full Terms Apply Visit Site
  10. Bet £10 & Get £30 in Free Bets

    18+ New Players only. For free bet wagering requirements and minimum odds read T&C’s. www.begambleaware.org Terms Apply 18+. Full T&C’s Apply. New customers on mobile only. 7 days to claim and stake £10 minimum bet at odds of 1.5 or greater to qualify. Free, void, cashed out or partially cashed out bets do not qualify. Max 3x £10 free bets credited on bet settlement. Free bets must be used on 4 or more selections with selection odds of 1.3 or greater. Free bets are non-withdrawable and stake not returned with winnings. 7 day expiry. Visit Site
Advertiser Disclosure
Every online gambler deserves a safe and fair place to play. Our mission at Gambling.com is to create a safe online environment for players through free, impartial and independent reviews of the UK's best online gambling companies so that you can play with confidence and security. All ratings and reviews are made independently of the operator by our team of gaming experts and with every company being fully UK licensed they can be trusted to offer fair play. We accept compensation from the companies advertised on this page and this may affect the brand positioning. We endeavour to continuously update this list so we can bring you the most current sites and the best available offers but we cannot review every site in the market.

Betting Strategy Articles

×