Watch: That's Offside Pundits Debate Who The Big Six Should Sign In January
As the January transfer window opens, the Premier League’s elite face defining decisions about how they approach the second half of the campaign.
From structural issues to squad depth, no club avoids scrutiny, as January often exposes how serious teams are about competing at the top or simply salvaging their season.
That's Offside invited Arsenal superfan Alex Moneypenny and staunch Liverpool supporter Laurence McKenna to dive headfirst into what the Premier League’s top six should be doing to fix their seasons.
Watch The Episode Here
Structural Problems And Squad Balance
Liverpool face pressing questions about their title defence and squad depth as last summer’s rebuild added energy but may have left short-term vulnerabilities.
Meanwhile, Manchester United’s issues are more fundamental: a persistent lack of midfield control and uncertainty over Bruno Fernandes’ role.
The guys agreed that United need a clearer tactical identity, not another stopgap solution.
Manchester City, in contrast, approach January from a position of relative strength.
Their focus is on insurance rather than urgency, prioritising contingency plans for Erling Haaland and versatile, system-driven players, such as new signing Antoine Semenyo.
Ambition, Depth And Defining Moments
As for Chelsea, their attacking problems are viewed as symptoms of deeper instability. Without a reliable goalkeeper–centre-back–number nine spine, progress remains fragile.
Arsenal’s title hopes may depend on midfield durability, as injuries or fatigue could expose limited depth in Arteta’s demanding system.
Not surprisingly, Tottenham provoke the strongest debate. Years of cautious January windows have shaped perceptions, making this a defining moment for the club’s ambition.
The consensus is clear: only a true statement signing will change how Spurs are viewed among the elite.
* Who would you like to see your club sign this January? Let us know in the comments below.
