Best MLB Prop Bets Today, Expert Predictions & Great Bonuses 05/23

Date IconLast Updated : Jun 8th, 2023
Share On Your Network
Best MLB Prop Bets Today, Expert Predictions & Great Bonuses 05/23
© PA

Best MLB Player Prop Bets Today:


Get ready for an action-packed evening of MLB games this Wednesday. Our dedicated team of experts has gone above and beyond to bring you the most captivating MLB prop bets from the industry's best online betting sites.

Through meticulous analysis of MLB odds from our trusted sports betting partners, combined with our own expert projections, we have unearthed numerous opportunities for you to find value within the exciting world of prop betting.

To explore all the available options, we encourage you to delve into our selection of the best MLB betting sites featured on These premier sportsbooks offer a wealth of enticing bonuses and noteworthy features. By signing up with all three featured sportsbooks, you can unlock up to $450 in bonus bets, empowering you to make your best MLB prop bets tonight!

With our expert analysis and the comprehensive resources at your fingertips, you'll be equipped to navigate the intricate landscape of MLB prop betting with confidence. Increase your chances of uncovering lucrative opportunities and maximize your excitement for the game.

Don't miss out on this exclusive chance to elevate your MLB betting experience. Explore our featured MLB betting sites now and seize the potential for big wins with our expert insights by your side.

Best MLB Prop Bet #1: Yordan Alvarez to record OVER 1.5 bases  (-143 at BetMGM Sportsbook)

Alvarez is poised to continue his impressive performance at the plate, making it highly likely that he will record over 1.5 bases. Currently ranked fifth among qualifying hitters in OPS (1.015), Alvarez has been on fire during his last 15 games. 

MLB Daily Stats reveals that he boasts an exceptional 221 wRC+ (where 100 wRC+ is the league average) and a formidable wOBA of .491 during this stretch. In the Astros' dominant 12-2 victory over the Brewers last night, Alvarez showcased his prowess by hitting two home runs and accumulating five RBIs.

Facing Milwaukee starter Colin Rea (0-3, 5.52 ERA, 5.54 FIP), Alvarez has a prime opportunity to continue his impressive run. With the Brewers missing three starters due to injury (Brandon Woodruff, Wade Miley, and Eric Lauer), Rea has been thrust into the starting rotation, and he has struggled to generate swings and misses (19th percentile in whiff rate) while also struggling to limit hard contact (24th percentile in hard-hit rate). 

This doesn't bode well for Rea when facing one of the game's most dangerous hitters like Alvarez. The increased likelihood of balls being put in play enhances the chances of Alvarez surpassing 1.5 total bases on Tuesday night. Get ready to witness Alvarez's offensive prowess once again.


REMINDER*** If you are looking to place your bet through BetMGM sportsbook, but you not have an account yet, we highly suggest you sign up and use BetMGM MLB Bonus Code GAMBLING100 and unlock up to $100 in bonus that you can use to make your best MLB prop bets today and entice your betting experience. 

Best MLB Prop Bet #2: Dylan Cease Over 17.5 outs recorded (-125 at bet365 Sportsbook)

Dylan Cease, despite a challenging season for the Chicago White Sox, is showing signs of regaining his form. While his strikeouts have decreased and his hard-hit rate has increased compared to his impressive performance in the previous season, Cease has recently strung together two quality starts, and we believe he has a strong chance of making it three in a row against the Cleveland Guardians.

Although Cease encountered a rough patch, notably when he allowed seven runs on nine hits in four innings against the Kansas City Royals, he has since rebounded. In his last two starts, he has only given up three earned runs on nine hits over 12 1/3 innings. Notably, one of those starts was against the same Guardians team he will face this time, where he pitched 6 1/3 innings. It wouldn't surprise us if he delivers a similar performance once again.

Cleveland's struggling lineup, especially against right-handed pitchers, adds to Cease's favorable prospects. The Guardians have a team batting average of just .230 against righties, ranking 26th in the league, and they also rank 29th in both OPS and wRC+.

Furthermore, Cease has experienced success against the Guardians in recent matchups. In his last four starts against them dating back to last July, he has only allowed four earned runs on 21 hits. He has pitched at least six innings in three of those games and never fewer than 5 2/3 innings.

Considering Cease's improving performance and his historical success against the Guardians, we are confident that he will continue to find his groove and exceed 17.5 outs at -125 with bet365 sportsbook. Get ready to witness Cease's solid performance on the mound.


REMINDER***  Want to join the MLB betting action early tonight? Why not sign up with bet365 sportsbook using the bonus code GAMBLING and unlock $200 in bonus bets for the best MLB prop bets tonight? 

Best MLB Prop Bet #3: Jorge Soler Over 0.5 Homers (+230 at DraftKings Sportsbook)

While we usually avoid homer prop bets with odds below +300 due to their difficulty, there are exceptions when all the factors align perfectly. Tonight, Jorge Soler falls into that category, making him an intriguing candidate to hit over 0.5 home runs.

First and foremost, Soler benefits greatly from playing at Coors Field. This renowned ballpark has a park factor of 1.301 for homers by right-handed batters, providing a significant boost to their power numbers. With the home run-friendly environment in play, Soler's chances of going deep are heightened.

Secondly, Soler has the platoon advantage in tonight's matchup. Against left-handed pitchers since 2021, he has been a force to be reckoned with, blasting 25 home runs in 276 plate appearances. Notably, this year alone, he has already smashed seven home runs in just 39 plate appearances against lefties. With his success against left-handed pitching, Soler has a favorable situation to capitalize on.

The matchup itself further supports Soler's quest for a home run. Austin Gomber, the opposing pitcher, has surrendered five home runs to the 90 right-handed hitters he has faced at Coors Field this year. Looking back to last year, Gomber has allowed a total of 16 home runs to the 311 right-handed hitters he has encountered at Coors Field. Given Gomber's track record, the stage is set for Soler to go deep against him.

Considering all these factors, we confident in chasing a home run from Soler and taking advantage of the best odds available at DraftKings Sportsbook. Don't miss out on the opportunity to wager on Soler to record over 0.5 homers at +230 power potential in this favorable situation.


REMINDER*** DraftKings sportsbook always finds a way to please its customers! Sign up today and claim a generous welcome bonus in the form of $150 in bonus bets for best MLB prop bets tonight. No code is required!!! 


Ensure you take full advantage of the exclusive bet365 bonus offer tailored specifically for new members! Join today and place a $1 bet to unlock an impressive $200 in bonus bets. Redeeming your bonus bets is a seamless process – simply make a qualifying bet of $1 or more on any event. Don't hesitate to seize this opportunity without delay.

No DraftKings Promo Code is necessary to benefit from the enticing "Bet $5 Get $150" bonus offer, as it can be accessed without one. Just register for a new account and make a pregame moneyline bet of $5 or more on the MLB. You will then receive the bonus bets, without any need for a DraftKings Promo Code.

Make sure you seize the chance to receive bonus bets of up to $1,000 by utilizing the special BetMGM bonus code GAMBLINGCOM, exclusively offered through Sign up immediately and capitalize on this time-sensitive promotion while enjoying the thrilling MLB season. Move fast to benefit from this opportunity and enhance your MLB betting journey.