43 State Attorneys General Ask CFTC To Drop Sports Event Contracts Swap Rule

Attorneys general from 43 states and the District of Columbia have asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its proposal to treat sports-related event contracts as swaps.
The rule is the one Kalshi has already cited in its appeal in the fight over who regulates prediction markets.
The bipartisan group filed a formal comment letter dated November 18, according to a release from Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, who co-led the effort.
Wilson is working alongside the attorneys general of Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah, and 35 more states and D.C. have signed on.
What The Coalition Argues
The attorneys general say the CFTC cannot classify sports bets as financial instruments called swaps and that doing so would take power Congress never gave the agency.
Their letter states that sports bets are not derivatives subject to CFTC jurisdiction.
They point to federal appellate court decisions that rejected the agency's claimed authority over sports betting, and they challenge its ability to adopt the rule at all, arguing it lacks the required quorum because only one commissioner is currently serving.
The coalition also warns that the proposal could encourage traditional sportsbooks to reorganise as prediction markets, which would sidestep state gambling laws and leave consumers without established safeguards.
It asks the commission to withdraw the rule and clarify that sports-betting contracts are not swaps.
A Second Rule Also Challenged
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown, a co-lead, said in his office’s release that the group of 44 attorneys general, counting D.C., opposed two federal rules.
One is an interim rule already in effect that treats only house-backed casino-style games as traditional gambling, and so not swaps.
The other is the proposal to extend the swap definition to sports and election betting, where bettors wager against each other.
Regarding the interim rule, the attorneys general said gambling has never been limited to house-backed games and that drawing the line there contradicts the rule's own reasoning, past CFTC guidance, and recent court decisions.
They warned that if certain forms of gambling, such as betting on horse races, were treated as swaps, selling those bets outside a CFTC-regulated exchange could become a crime.
What Consumers And Operators Should Watch
Wilson's office said prediction markets let users wager on sporting events much as sportsbooks do, but without the same state oversight.
It said the proposed rule could open the door for these platforms to bypass licensing requirements, age restrictions and protections against problem gambling.
The letter follows a July 2026 effort in which Ohio co-led a coalition of 44 attorneys general urging the CFTC to recognise states' long-standing authority over sports-related prediction markets.
For the wider picture, see our explainer on the fight between the CFTC and the states.
The commission now has to weigh the comments before deciding whether to finalise, change or drop the proposal.
Refer to Cashback Terms & Conditions for full program terms.
